Malaysian women redefine gender roles in technology

You are here

Malaysian women redefine gender roles in technology

by Ruth Schechter on Monday, February 8, 2010 - 6:51am

Ulf still.croppedAccording to national studies, women hold more than half of all professional occupations in the U.S. but fewer than 24 percent of all computing-related occupations, representing a huge pool of untapped talent. The numbers are not moving in favor of increasing women’s participation in technology; in 2008 women earned only 18 percent of all computer science degrees. Back in 1985, women earned 37 percent of CS degrees, nearly double today’s share.

As technology becomes ever more pervasive and powerful, why aren’t more women clamoring to take part in the surge? Do these dwindling numbers reveal a faulty system that discourages women from entering the field? Or is it a reflection of intrinsic perceptions of gender strengths and weaknesses?

The answer may lie in Malaysia, where women make up between 50 and 60 percent of the computer industry’s employees and many hold mid- and upper-level management positions. The country’s burgeoning technology industry has brought about dramatic changes to women’s roles in society, changing traditional perceptions of class, ethnicity and gender.

“In the U.S., technology and masculinity are very connected, which is not the case in Malaysia,” said Ulf Mellstrom, a professor of gender and technology at Luleå University of Technology in Sweden and a Clayman faculty research fellow, who discussed the topic at a presentation called The Intersection of Gender, Race and Cultural Boundaries: or Why is Computer Science in Malaysia Dominated by Women? “In a short time, booming industrialization has created new opportunities for women while transforming and reforming established society.”

The author of “Masculinity, Power and Technology: A Malaysian Ethnography,” Mellstrom has been conducting a long-term survey of female students in preparation for a new book on Malaysian women in the computer industry. In contrast to the U.S., in Malaysia jobs in technology are seen as appropriate for women: Men do not perceive indoor work as masculine and much of society stigmatizes women who work outdoors as lower class. Computing and programming are seen as “women-friendly” professions, with opportunities opening up since men are not interested in competing for these types of jobs. “It’s a woman’s world in that respect,” said Mellstrom.

Tsunami Alert Centre-Malaysia

Tsunami Alert Centre (Bloomberg/Getty Images)

Initially women left their villages to seek urban opportunities in the electronics industry, where their dexterity and willingness to take on indoor production work created a massive new workforce. As electronics jobs were replaced by technological ones, the field opened up to newly educated women who easily assumed positions of authority in a field that is nontraditional by nature. This transition, in part, was streamlined because women in computer science had role models in their electronic predecessors, a sequence that does not really exist in the U.S. computer science industry, said Mellstrom.

Malay women in particular see education as a way to become more independent. In the cities, this new breed of young, independent, skilled women is overwhelmingly represented in the computer industry.

According to Mellstrom, the critical mass of women in computer sciences continues to provide role models for other women and establishes “a symbolic space” where it can be demonstrated that women can—and do—excel in the field. And because the boom has caused such a critical shortage of well-trained computer and information technology specialists, Malaysian industries tend to welcome new members of the professional community.

Responses to Malaysian women redefine gender roles in technology


ady
's picture
24 February, 2010 ady (not verified)

How are women in Malaysia redefining gender roles when your article explicitly states that the reason the percentage is so high is that Malaysian society views indoor jobs to be non-masculine and women in outdoor jobs are to be of lesser class? The premise of this article is laughably flawed because the author is attempting to compare a Malaysian situation to US societal roles and call it revolutionary. The fact that these women went from rural homes to offices does, and the fact that they are excelling in their fields does not change the stated fundamental views of their society and, contrary to what the article states, the situation of Malaysia's women is entirely reinforced by their perceived gender roles, not vice versa.


kaz
's picture
24 February, 2010 kaz (not verified)

This situation could in fact be due to the fundamental views of Malaysian society, which discourages women from being aggressive and overt. Also, female students are generally perceived to be more hardworking than male students.


Andrew
's picture
14 August, 2010 Andrew (not verified)

I personally think that it is downright fantastic that women in Malaysia are getting there proper respect due to them


Steven Jackson
's picture
20 November, 2010 Steven Jackson (not verified)

The fact that one country like Malaysia can go against the average like that is really quite revealing. What it suggests to me in my perception is that IT and information technology type jobs are not highly valued to provide these types of statistics. I believe this trend is also rising in the other countries where a lot of outsourcing of mundane data entry tasks are done. Still interesting statists, though. Enjoyed reading your post.


Dinesh Bogati
's picture
16 December, 2010 Dinesh Bogati (not verified)

Feminist criticism deals with the subject matter about the women and their role in society. There is still patriarchy society in the most part of the world and even male chauvinism ideology is prevailing in the society. In this context, Malaysian women have challenged to such concept. This vital information about the contribution of women in technological field should be spread all over the world.


Diana
's picture
14 March, 2011 Diana (not verified)

More than half of the engineering classes in Malaysia are filled with women. Even the oil and gas industry have women working outdoor as geologists and engineers. As a Malaysian woman, I do not agree with the writer's statement that "men do not perceive indoor work as masculine and much of society stigmatizes women who work outdoors as lower class".

Post a New Response